| Rev C. Stuart Franklin | 1887 – 1888(Initially based at Millwood) |
| Rev Richard P. Underwood | 1889 – 1893 |
| Rev Frederick Holmes | 1893 – 1894 |
| Rev Herbert S. Few | 1894 – 1895 |
| Rev Joseph Green Locke | 1895 – 1898 |
| Rev George S. Barber | 1898 – 1899 |
| Rev Alfred Eben Griffin | Supply during 1900 |
| Rev J. Chamberlain | Supply during 1900 |
| Rev Edward Frank Piper | 1900 – 1904 |
| Rev Owen R. Thompson | 1904 – 1907 |
| Rev Arthur Herbert Barnes | 1907 – 1909 |
| Rev Arthur John Owen Killick | 1909 – 1912 |
| Rev William Henry Irving | 1912 – 1917 |
| Rev Francis Weir | 1916 – 1920 |
| Rev James Marriner | 1920 – 1926 |
| Rev Leonard Scott Creed | 1926 – 1931 |
| Rev John William Woodthorne Owen | 1931 – 1932 |
| Rev A.E. House | Supply during 1932 |
| Rev Arthur J. Clarke | Supply during 1932 |
| Rev R.J. Thompson | 1933 |
| Rev Rayner Speight | 1934 – 1937 |
| Rev Frank Edwards | Supply during 1937 |
| Rev Joseph Marsh Alistoun | 1938 – 1942 |
| Rev Duncan M. Wyllie | 1943 |
| Rev Owen R. Thompson | 1943 – 1945 |
| Rev Joseph H. Boyd | 1946 – 1949 |
| Rev Edward Percival Spencer | 1950 – 1951 |
| Rev Owen R. Thompson | Supply during 1951 |
| Rev Nendick Paul Abraham | 1952 – 1955 |
| Rev Percy C. Oliff | 1956 – 1958 |
| Rev Roy McKenzie Fraser | 1959 – 1960 |
| Rev Frederick E. Bunker | 1960 – 1962 |
| Rev Charles W. Moore | 1963 |
| Rev Arthur Colledge | 1964 – 1968 |
| Rev Robert C. Bellis | 1969 – 1971 |
| Rev Jan Erasmus | 1971 – 1975 |
| Rev Henry Lague | 1976 – 1977 |
| Rev Michael L. Mackintosh | 1978 – 1981 |
| Rev Roy S. Baker | Supply during 1982 |
| Rev Albery Greyling | 1983 – 1989 |
| Rev Gavin J. Leverton | 1990 – 1994 |
| Rev Peter Abbott | 1995 – 2001 |
| Rev James Gribble | 2002 – 2005 |
| Rev Debbie van der Laar | 2005 – 2009 |
| Rev Rodney Jamieson | 2009-2022 |
| Rev Siya Mandla | 2022 – Present |
Want to get in touch? Please feel free to call us on 076 905 0964 or email us at admin@knysnamethodist.org